Why Would A Poor Black Kid Love Sherlock Holmes?


📣 Greetings, fellow lovers of fiction — and mystery in particular!

🔍 Edited Monograph:

Why Sherlock?
Why would a poor Black boy love Sherlock Holmes?

What was the appeal?

Why mystery?

Why admire a man who stood beside — and sometimes behind — the great colonizers of human history?

After all, Watson was a medical doctor and a soldier in Afghanistan.
England had invaded the Middle East, India, Africa, and lord knows where else.

But Holmes…
He was a loner.
An odd man out.
His own man.

A savant in a world that had no real understanding of that condition.

He was damaged — yet laser-focused in his pursuit of something resembling justice.

Selfish, yes. But a selfishness that benefited many.

He was loyal to the one true person who let him be who he was.
He was a hero who didn’t pursue the title, nor even see himself as one.

Though sometimes dismissive of social rules and rank, he was a man of honor.
And that struck me.

I was raised in a time when there were few — if any — Black heroes.
Certainly not in the mainstream media.
So I had a choice: accept invisibility… or become selective.
Pull wisdom and wonder from what was available.

Holmes rarely judged someone solely by status or wealth.
Good and evil knew no social gates — and Holmes knew this all too well.

He appealed to me as a character.
As a detective.
As a thinker who didn’t rely on violence to solve his problems.

He didn’t seek praise.
But he earned respect.
He made things better.
And aside from Watson, he survived — and eventually thrived — on his own terms.

That mattered to me more back then. Because sometimes I felt alone.

I admired the mood.
I admired the man.
But most of all…
I loved unraveling the mysteries.

Best,
Alex Simmons

PS: If you haven't picked up your free preview of the first two scenes, feel free to click right here.

Simmons Says

Hi, Alex Simmons here. I've taught 100s of aspiring and struggling writers how to overcome their fears and frustrations and create compelling plots, characters, and stories that appeal to a broader audience. Over the years, I've been honored to be a professional author (award-winner), writing coach/teacher, and consultant. I’ve written for many mainstream publishers, Marvel/DC/Archie Comics, and penned plays, interactive games, and video and animation scripts. And I’ve been a global speaker on empowering people through the arts. I have much to share, starting with my Simmons Says Newsletter.

Read more from Simmons Says

Welcome to my newsletter! "It was like every childhood nightmare I'd ever faced!" Reader, I don’t remember the first thing I sold as a writer. I was young—somewhere in my twenties. Maybe even early twenties. I think it was an interview with a musician for a small, fledgling industry magazine. Nothing glamorous. And at that time, I had no idea that years later I would face one of the darkest, scariest challenges a writer can encounter. Let me take you there.The year was 2020. It was during...

Welcome to my newsletter! “Building Better Mystery Characters—Without Overthinking It" Holy excitement, Batman! Uh, Reader, A mystery lives or dies on its characters. Not the twist.Not the reveal.Not even the crime itself. If we don’t believe the people involved—if we don’t understand what they want, what they’re hiding, and what they’re afraid to lose—then the mystery becomes a puzzle instead of a story. And puzzles don’t bleed. Better mystery characters aren’t created by adding...

Welcome to my newsletter! “To be persuasive, we must be believable; to be believable, we must be credible; to be credible, we must be truthful.” —Edward R. Murrow-- Hey, Reader, There’s something I think about a lot—and maybe you do too—especially if you’re a writer or storyteller of any kind. It’s the question of ethics. Because being a writer, in any form, requires us to make conscious, ethical decisions about what we put into the world. Whether we’re writing for the entertainment world,...